Cedar shake roofs have long been admired for their natural beauty and classic curb appeal. They give homes a warm, timeless look that many homeowners in Minnesota find irresistible. However, as these roofs age, the challenges of maintaining them often outweigh their charm.

The Challenges of Cedar Shake Roofs

While cedar shake offers stunning aesthetics, it comes with several drawbacks over time:
  • High maintenance requirements due to weathering, splitting, and moss growth
  • Shorter lifespan compared to modern roofing materials
  • Frequent repairs as the wood naturally deteriorates
  • Increased susceptibility to moisture damage and fire risk (depending on treatment and environment)
Another growing concern: Many insurance companies are no longer covering cedar shake roofs.
Due to the higher risk of fire and the increasing cost of claims, some insurers are dropping coverage, non-renewing policies, or charging significantly higher premiums for homes with cedar shake. This can leave homeowners facing difficult choices and much higher out-of-pocket costs.
As a result, many homeowners find themselves spending more time and money on upkeep than they originally anticipated.

Why Homeowners Are Switching to Composite Shingles

Composite shingles are an excellent alternative because they are designed to replicate the rich, textured look of cedar shake while delivering superior performance and durability.
Key advantages include:
  • Exceptional durability resistant to cracking, curling, and rot
  • Significantly lower maintenance needs, saving you time and money
  • Better resistance to harsh Minnesota weather conditions
  • Consistent appearance that holds up without the natural wear of real wood
  • Longer lifespan, making it a smarter long-term investment
  • Often easier to insure, with many companies offering better rates and coverage
With composite shingles, homeowners no longer have to compromise between beauty and performance.

The Opportunity for Homeowners

Many homeowners do not realize their cedar shake roof has reached the point where ongoing repairs are no longer the most cost-effective solution, especially with changing insurance policies. This creates a valuable opportunity to evaluate the roof before small issues turn into costly leaks or interior damage.
By acting proactively, you can transition to a roofing system that better meets your long-term needs for durability, low maintenance, and lasting beauty.

How Les Jones Roofing Can Help

At Les Jones Roofing, we specialize in helping homeowners assess the true condition of their existing cedar shake roof. We provide honest, clear guidance on whether repair, restoration, or a full replacement with composite shingles is the best choice for your home.
Our goal is simple: to bring clarity to your roofing decision and deliver solutions that protect your home for years to come.
If your home has a cedar shake roof, now is the perfect time to have it professionally evaluated. Switching to composite shingles could be the upgrade your home needs.
About The Author
Jason Iwig – Sales Manager, Les Jones Roofing
Jason’s Profile: Linkedin
email: [email protected]
Phone: (952) 881 224
Jason’s is trusted and Knowledgeble recognized craftsman for 20+ years. Backed by the strength of a 40+ year local legacy, Jason represents the values that define Les Jones Roofing: integrity, accountability, craftsmanship, and trust. His goal is not just to complete a project—but to build long-term relationships and be a partner clients can rely on for years to come.